Choose your location

Latest
I Am Helen review – Nicola Coughlan is absolutely superb in this terrifying must-watch Mauricio Pochettino sends coaches to Manchester to help prepare for United job Robert Pattinson’s journey from Harry Potter and Twilight to James Bond: ‘The honour of a lifetime’ 'Loaded with potential': stage version of TV smash It's a Sin has the dancefloor at its heart ‘Pull back the curtain’ on treatment of sexual assault victims in court, says UK government adviser Tanzid Tamim rues 'unlucky' last-ball dismissal for Towhid Hridoy

Brandon Lowe is a better Yankees fit than Luis Arraez

Brandon Lowe hit 35 home runs this year. Luis Arraez struck out 28 times. Both figures are good reasons for the Yankees to make a phone call. Only one player makes sense to me as a primary target if second...

Empire Sports Media @AlexWilsonESM

Brandon Lowe hit 35 home runs this year. Luis Arraez struck out 28 times. Both figures are good reasons for the Yankees to make a phone call.

Only one player makes sense to me as a primary target if second base actually opens up, and it’s the one who can change the score with a swing. Bryan Hoch reported for MLB.com that New York checked in on Lowe and Arraez, without reporting a deal or an offer for either. Jazz Chisholm Jr. is a free agent and has drawn broad interest, per the same report.

Anthony Volpe, José Caballero and Luis García Jr. are among the internal possibilities. “I’m not saying anybody’s our second baseman, our center fielder, our first baseman or DH,” Cashman told Hoch. The second-base call shouldn’t get made in isolation.

If the club finds its power in center or at first, the cheaper second-base option starts making more sense. If the lineup stays short on damage against righties, that’s where Lowe has an edge. The salaries could land far apart, and the cost to sign Lowe may not stop at the salary.

Pittsburgh extended Lowe a $23.15 million qualifying offer . If he declines and signs elsewhere, his new team faces a draft-related cost under MLB’s qualifying-offer rules . Arraez didn’t receive one .

That makes Arraez cheaper to acquire in one important way, but doesn’t make the bats interchangeable. Why the Yankees should look at the righty split first Lowe hit .279 with a .550 slugging percentage against righties , putting up a .910 OPS and 27 of his 35 homers in those matchups.

Arraez hit .308 with a .418 slugging percentage against righties , with a .765 OPS across his two clubs. Those 29 points of batting average are useful. The 132-point difference in slugging is why I’d pay more for Lowe.

Sep 23, 2026; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; St. Louis Cardinals right fielder Jordan Walker (18) steals second bases as Pittsburgh Pirates second baseman Brandon Lowe (5) looks for a throw during the fifth inning at PNC Park. Mandatory Credit: Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images Credit: IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect Flip the matchup and the comparison gets less comfortable.

Lowe had a .648 OPS against lefties, below Arraez’s .764. So I’d spend starter money on Lowe because right-handed pitching makes up so much of the schedule, not because I think he should own every at-bat. Keep a credible right-handed second baseman on the roster who can start against difficult lefties or come in when the opposing bullpen lines up that way.

Lowe’s defensive improvement with Pittsburgh gives him a better argument to stay at second than he had a year ago. MLB.com reported that his fielding run value went from minus 10 to plus 12. I wouldn’t pay for the high number as if it were guaranteed.

A swing that large is reason to look at the positioning and the plays around the bag, not assume Pittsburgh found a version of him the Yankees are certain to get. If Chisholm is still in reach, compare that contract to Lowe’s before choosing. If both get expensive, I’d start with the internal options and spend the difference on pitching.

Arraez is worth revisiting if the team decides it needs the contact somewhere else on the roster. I wouldn’t buy it as a substitute for the damage Lowe does against righties. Mentioned in this article: brandon lowe Yankees More about: New York Yankees

Article text via FreeNewsAPI. Rights remain with Empire Sports Media.

Read on publisher site → Opens Empire Sports Media in a new tab

More in Local

Local

Science news in review: Nov. 16

The semester may be drawing to a close, but there is no end for the world of scientific discovery! Take a moment to consider the latest and…

The Johns Hopkins News-Letter